After reading Dr. Winand's release on the origin of WFFS (warmblood fragile foal syndrome), it stirred my continuing frustration with the Arabian mythology the permeates our industry. First, let me state this is not a criticism of the Arabian Horse itself, as any sport horse breeder will attest the Arabian is an excellent endurance horse, and we all admire their saddle qualities and refinement. This is rather about the Arabian culture teachings that are fantasy, that is, not supported by evidence and yet somehow persist century after century. Further, this is not a criticism of Dr. Winand's work either, just the prevailing operating theory that still, no matter how much evidence to the contrary, persists: that the Arabian is the foundation of the Thoroughbred, and the supplier of the speed.
And here, in Dr. Winand's release, she identifies one of her working premises: "...Thoroughbreds which are descended largely from multiple Arabians." In the report if we read carefully (it took me a couple of reads and communicating with the Dr.), we can see Dr. Winand is at odds with the Westphalian association stating that WFFS came through Dark Ronald (Bay Ronald) Thoroughbred line. She made a very strong point that the 'real' culprit is further back and in the desert-bred Arabian. She has found a Dark Ronald ancestor with a history of stillbirths in its descendants, which she does not identify, a horse that apparently is one of the Orientals with no parentage that pepper the background of Thoroughbred pedigrees, and deducted that it had to be desert-bred because it had no pedigree?
This is my issue: it is probably not a Arabian to begin with, because we have learned very few of those so named are in fact Arabian, and that it has no parentage does not mean it was bred in the desert. (The Turks for example, carefully bred their horses for centuries before they arrived in the English gene pool, usually in royal studs, often given as diplomatic gifts because of their excellence, and they did not come with lineage or it was not recorded on arrival). She does name the Godolphin Arabian as an example of a desert-bred Arabian, but that contradicts her peer Dr. Wallner's DNA work which determined that the founding sires of the Thoroughbred were Turks, not Arabians, plus multiple equine historians and pedigree examiners like MacKay-Smith, C. M. Prior, and our contemporary James R. Hardiman, have uncovered pedigree errors and false labels on many of the these horses (see their works listed in the References area at the end of this article). The reality is that very few true Arabians entered the Thoroughbred breed.
[Bloody Shouldered Arabian, one of the few true Arabians that entered the Thoroughbred gene pool. It was a failure at racing and not quite a total failure at stud as he had a few good racers.]
So, what do I mean by Arabian mythology? I will just concentrate on two of the most common themes in my experience: 1. The Arabian is the source of speed to the Thoroughbred, 2. The Arabian is one of the oldest purebred breeds in the world. There is no evidence that I know of that supports these claims, yet they have been passed on for centuries. What is going on? Finally, I got an intelligent explanation from someone that has spent years researching the true origin of the Arabian and the fantasy literature that surrounds it. This scholar traces the myths to a phase of 'Orientalism' in English colonization of the east wherein the Arabian Horse was portrayed in a romanticized fashion. See the "Bloody Shouldered Pegasus" article link below for an example of this type of literature. The fallout from this propaganda phase is massive, with many people of standing jumping on board and expanding it, such as the Arabian breeder Lady Wentworth (owner of Crabbit Arabian Stud), who in many of her writings promoted the Arabian mythology as truth.
In my own research on these phenomena I found some causative factors: King James promoted the Arabian and encouraged its use by breeders, and the General Stud Book demanded that all entries must trace on both sides of the pedigree to Oriental horses. Of course, this resulted in horses mysteriously gaining Oriental ancestry, horses having Arabian added to their names, and made up pedigrees so they could gain entry to the register. But there is more to be learned on the subject.
Let me introduce you to Hylke Hettema, a Phd candidate at Leiden University in The Netherlands, equestrian and horse breeder. She works on the connection between the horse and the Arab identity and has presented the following two articles to the general public:
"The Bloody Shouldered Pegasus" (an example of the mythology being spread)
"Ancient Arabians? A Closer Look at Ancient Egyptian Horses" (archaeological evidence on the real protoype, this study co-authored by Lonneke Delpeut, a MA of Egyptology at Leiden U.)
More scholarly versions of her work have been presented at the World Conference for Middle East Studies, as well as at the Equine History Conference. And in July 2018 she presented " How an Oriental war horse became a European trophy horse: the Arabian 'improvement theory'. You can visit her work and updates at her website.
It has always been a puzzle to me how the Arabian was claimed to be the source of speed to the Thoroughbred when it has never won a race against a Thoroughbred, even a part-Thoroughbred or the pre-Thoroughbred English racehorse: the English Running Horse; it always lost the match races, and they weren't even close finishes . And this fact was known before there was a stud book, for back in the 1700s, the Duke of Cumberland, the breeder of both Herod and Eclipse, did breeding experiments, and he concluded that the Arabian cross lessened speed in the breed, never improved it.
The Arabian myth spread everywhere the English horse went; for example, did you know our first President, George Washington, called any English bred horse a Arabian? Well, he did, and when he and Harry 'Light Horse' Lee brought the English Running Horse/Barb Ranger to Virginia from Connecticut, they changed the name to Lindsays Arabian, which resulted in generations of American equestrians thinking the Arabian was an essential portion of the American Horse. No true Arabian Horse entered the United States until 1800.
One of the most tragic examples of damage done from romanticized Arabian beliefs, is found with the destruction of speed in the herd of the wealthy 19th century Kentucky breeder, A. Keene Richards. From his exposure to this mythical industry narrative, he became certain that adding pure Arabian into his herd would improve speed. Being a man of means he traveled to Arabia and sought out the best stallions he could buy, and he brought two of them home to improve his herd. He even had their portraits painted by Troye. The project was a disaster and like everyone before him and after who attempted it, he found the Arab cross lessened his herd's speed. Yet to this day most articles on the Arabian Horse proclaim it a source of speed. It is just not true.
( A purebred Arabian, image by Trescastillos and made available for public use by Wiki Commons]
What does DNA have to say? Does the Arabian possess the newly discovered speed gene? No, it does not. What it does possess and homozygous is the newly isolated stamina gene (or factor). Now isn't that surprising a breed that excels in endurance is homozygous for the stamina gene? (Polaski)
On the 'most ancient of purebred breeds' nonsense, Hylke has shown what is called the proto-Arabian, the Egyptian Horse, was not an Arab, but in reality was just the original Egyptian Horses, many of them pintos, and related to the modern Egyptian Baladi Horse. Some studies say that the first recorded lineage of the Arabian dates back to 1330 AD. But does that population or stud operation actually connect via pedigree to the modern Arabian? I have not found any real evidence that Arabs bred a purebred horse until the 1800s. Saying 'desert bred' where a recorded ancestor belongs does not cut it, and in no way explains breed development, indeed, we have our own desert bred horses right here: mustangs, and no one is trying to claim they are pure-bred. When I extend the Arabian pedigrees their ancestries vanish quickly. Some lines extend into the 1800s, but not many.
What about the historical record? In ancient accounts of battles where Arabian tribes fought, never have I read they were mounted on horses or had horse powered chariots. Instead consistently, the record reports that the Arabs rode camels, and were very efficient in troop movement with them. Even in the Old Testament of our Bible, the accounts of the Arabs (Ishmaelites, Jokanites, Keturahites, Hagrites etc.) give us great details of their camel culture, how they had camel caravans moving goods from one area to another, describing the gold ornaments hanging from the camel bridles and the saddle clothes in great detail. The Old Testament contains the most accurate accounting of the ancient Arabian tribes. On the other hand, it is well documented that the Babylonians rode horses and drove horse drawn chariots, as did the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the later Philistines, but the Arabs? No, they rode camels. The truth is horse breeding came relatively late to the Arabians, and while they did develop an admirable breed, it is not one of the most ancient breeds in the world.
In 2013 Dr. Barbara Wallner and her team set out to determine origins of the modern breeds using Y chromosome tracing and they theorized that all modern horses trace to just two subclades: the Turk and the Arab. I can understand the Turkoman as that population was at the foundation point of the domestic horse, but the Arabian? The Arabian subclade includes the Arabs, Barbs, Draft and pony breeds. I thought maybe they too are assuming the Egyptian and north Africa horses descend from the Arab? That thinking doesn't make sense as the Arab appeared at least 1500 years after the Egyptian and Barb and even the Spanish Horse of the southern Iberian Peninsula. I am not debating that the Arab genetically falls in this group, but is a descendant not the foundation of it.
I wish they would clear up all this silliness. The Arabian Horse does not need fantasy claims to promote or validate it, because it is rated a fine light horse breed with tremendous stamina all on its own.
[An Arabian Horse performing the extreme Tevis Cup endurance challenge, a 100 mile endurance race over the most difficult terrain in the Sierra foothills. Image taken by Pascal Mario-Bourgeat and generously made available to the public via Wiki Commons]
It is a testament to the stellar qualities of the Arabian Horse that it dominates the entries and winners of the Tevis Cup, a full 85% of winners are pure Arabian or half Arabian. Nothing further needs to be said.
On a similar subject, read how our own equine history has been hidden from us by the political moves of a powerful group of breeders :The Thoroughbred Cult
In 1897, John Wallace published the following assessment of the ancient horse in his landmark work: The Horse in America, its History and Derivation, p. 2-4; stating 130 years before our day of DNA proofs, that the Arabian horse only accounts for only 2 or 3 percent of the genetics of the Thoroughbred--and that the Arabian is not the most ancient horse by a long shot. I stand in awe of him sometimes, that through just impeccable historical research and determination to get to the truth of things, how accurate he was so many times.
"But in the very center of all popular horse knowledge will be found a vital error that has dominated, to a large extent, the whole history of the past three hundred years. If you ask a dozen horsemen of average intelligence, 'What country was the original habitat of the horse?' a majority of them will answer, Arabia. It you put the same question to the same number of writers on the horses, everyone of them will answer, Arabia...
"...Armenia, Media, Cappadocia, and indeed all the countries bordering on the Black and Caspian Seas, were abundantly supplied with horses at least eighteen hundred years before the Christian era, At this time Egypt had no horses, but about one hundred years later, as shown by the history of Joseph and the inscriptions on her monuments, she had received a supply. At the very beginning of the Christian era, Strabo, the Greek geographer and historian, informs us Arabia had no horses. In the year 356 AD the Emperor Constantius sent to the prince of the country now called Yemen, in Arabia Felix, two hundred 'well bred Cappadocian horses' as a present. This is the first introduction of the horse into Arabia, so far as we have any tracings or indications of history, and thus the error of more than two thousand years is exposed.
"Many of the more conservative and thoughtful writers have maintained that the original habitat of the horse was on the steppes of Asia, but I have never been able to discover any reasonable basis for such an hypothesis. It seems to rest chiefly on two conditions, viz. 'That there were vast multitudes of horses running wild on the steppes; and , second, that the Barbarians brought their horses with them when they overran Europe; hence , as they argue, the horses must have been indigenous in that region. The first of these ideas will not hold without some shadow of proof, for it is overthrown by our own experience on our own continent; and so as to the second, the whole of Southern Europe, including Britain, and the whole of Northern Africa, were amply supplied with horses many centuries before the hordes from Asia made their appearance. Besides all this, there is no evidence, either in reason or history, that there ever was a period when the horse was not the companion, friend, and servant of man.
"The several facts, conditions, and circumstances pointing to Armenia as the original home of the horses, ...has afforded me a succession of most agreeable surprises in their approximate completeness. The salubrity of the climate, and the varied and abundant productions of the soil, and the ten thousand streams of pure water flowing from the mountains furnished a home and a breeding place just suited to the best of all animal creation, whether man or beast. To this fitness of the environment we can add the historical fact that more than eighteen hundred years before the Christian era horses abounded there in great numbers and of most excellent quality. To this we may add the other fact, that this is the first incidence in all history, sacred or profane, so far as we have discovered, in which horses are spoken of. The Armenians are the oldest people on the face of the earth, inhabiting the same territory in which they grew into a nation. They are direct descendants of Japheth, the son of Noah, and they spread out from their original home, at the foot of the mountains of Ararat. They grew into a mighty nation, and at one time their dominion extended from the Mediterranean to the Caspian . The supremacy of the tribal relation was maintained until Haic or Haicus, the great grandson of Japheth, became a ruler of his people. Descending from him, in the direct male line, there were five or six long reigns before the dynasty was overthrown by the Assyrians. They were largely an agricultural people, and the ancient historians have told us they were famous for the great numbers and fine quality of the horses they produced. The market for their horses, the prophet Ezekel tells us, was in the great commercial city of Tyre, whence they were carried 'in the ships of Tarshish' by the Phoenician merchants to all portions of the known world. Having here reached back to the Noahic period and country, with all that implies, I will leave the problem, with the more extended consideration that will be given it in the chapter on the general distribution of horses in all parts of the commercial world.
"Horsemen of average intelligence and writers on the horse, oftentimes much below average intelligence in horse matters, all seem to unite on the Arabian horse as their fetish, when in fact they know nothing about him. The songs of the poets and the stories of novelists have taken the place, in the minds of the people of all nations, of solid history and sober experince. When a story writer wished to depict an athletic and daring hero, he never fails to mount him on a 'Arab steed', when some blood-curdling adventure are to be disclosed. When Admiral Rous, the great racing authority in England, announced some years ago, that the English race horse was purely descended from the horses of the Arabian Deserta, without one drop of plebian blood, all England believed him, and this rash and groundless dictum has served all writers as conclusive evidence ever since. Now, it is not probable that more than two or at most three percent of the blood of the English race horse as he stands to-day is Arabian blood. The greatness and value of the Arabian horse is purely mythical. He has been tested hundreds of times, both on the course and in the stud, and in every single instance he has proved a failure."
Bower, Dr. Mim (et al) "The cosmopolitan maternal heritage of the Thoroughbred racehorse breed shows a significant contribution from British and Irish native mares." 2010
Bowling, Ann T. Horse Genetics 1996
Hardiman, James R. Thoroughbred Breeding - Early Ancestors (www.bloodliines.net/highflyer/)
Herbert, Henry Frank Forester's Horse and Horsemanship of the United States and British Province of North America volumes I & II 1857
Hettema, Hylke (https://rememberingadeserthorse.org) "Bloodly Shouldered Pegasus" 2017, "Ancient Arabian? A Closer Look at Ancient Egyptian Horses" 2018, "How a Oriental war horse became a European trophy horse- the Arabian 'improvement theory' 2018
Hervey, John Racing in America 1665-1865 1944, "Racing and Breeding in American" 1931, Racing and Breeding in Canada" 1931
Hill, Dr. Emmeline et al. " History and Intregrity of Thoroughbred Dam Lines Revealed in Equine mtDNA Variation" 2002, "The genetic origin and history of speed in the Thoroughbred racehorse" 2012, " A sequence polymorhism in MSTN predicts sprinting ability and racing stamina in Thoroughbred horses" 2011
Hodges, James Ph.D "George Washington's Horses" 2009
Jansen, Thomas et al " Mitochondrial DNA and the origins of the domestic horse" 2002
Kirsan, Kathleen North American Sport Horse Breeder 2013, Legacy of Lexington 2014, Standardbred Sport Horses 2017, www.sport-horse-breeder.com/irish-hobby.html, www.sport-horse-breeder.com/origin-sport-ability.html, www.sport-horse-breeder.com/origin-sport-british.html, www.sport-horse-breeder.com/thoroughbred-soundness.html, www.sport-horse-breeder.com/warmblood-fragile-foal-syndrome.html
MacKay-Smith, Alexander Speed and the Thoroughbred-the complete history 2000, The Race Horses of America 1832-1872 (portraits and other paintings by Edward Troye)
Performance Genetics "The Speed Gene" 2014 (http://performancegenetics.com)
Petersen, Jessica L. et al "Genome-Wide Analysis Reveals Selection for Important Traits in Domestic Horse Breeds" 2013
Polaski, Dr. Daniel "Detection and Analysis of Polymorphisms in the Promate Region of Equine PPARGCIA Gene" 2018
Prior, Christopher M. Early Recording of the Thoroughbred Horse 1924
Robertson, William H.P. The History of Thoroughbred Racing in America 1964
Royo, L.J. et al " The Origins of Iberian Horses Assessed via Mitochondrial DNA" 2005
Smith, Odhran " A review and criticism of the research article: Mitochondrial DNA sequence diversity in the extant Irish Horse populations and in ancient horses" 2009
Thoroughbred Genetics "Thoroughbred Genetics identifies performance genes in racehorses and publishes ground breaking research" www.thoroughbredgenetics.com
Vila, Carlos et al " Widespread Origins of Domestic Horse Lineages" 2001
Wallace, John The Horse of America in his Derivation, History, and Development 1897
Wallner, Dr. Barbara "Y Chromosome Uncovers the Recent Oriental Origin of Modern Stallions" 2017
Washington, George "The Papers of George Washington" The University of Virginia Press 2009
Wentworth, Lady The World's Best Horse 1958, The Swift Runner: racing speed through the ages 1957, Thoroughbred Racing Stock and its Ancestors: the authority of pure blood 1938
Winand, Dr. Nena " Origins of WFFS Identified: Furioso xx Opened Door Through Bay Ronald" 2019, Personal correspondence 3/29/2019